Mechanical pumps for extracorporeal circulation
Christopher Brabant, perfusionist, Children's Hospital of Wisconsin
Developing a mechanical blood pump to temporarily replace the function of the human heart has been the focus of physiologic and engineering research since the early 1900s. The ideal blood pump would have a controllable stroke volume and would be capable of producing a wide range of outputs. The output would be relatively independent of the resistance to fluid flow in the perfusion circuit and patient. Furthermore, the pumping motion would not damage the cellular or acellular components of the blood. All parts of the blood pump circuit in contact with the bloodstream would be disposable. It would have a smooth, continuous surface with negligible dead spaces so that stagnation and turbulence are kept to a minimum. Calibration of the pump flow would be exact and reproducible so that blood flow could be accurately monitored. Finally, the ideal pump would be manually operable in the event of a power failure.
Although no ideal exists, there are four types of pumps available. The two most commonly used are the roller and centrifugal pump. Both are used at Children's Hospital of Wisconsin for cardiopulmonary bypass and extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO).
Both roller pumps and centrifugal pumps have advantages and disadvantages.
Roller pumps contain mechanical parts that trap a portion of the fluid and propel it forward. The design of this pump combines a 210º semicircular backing plate and twin rollers that are 180º out of phase with one another. A length of tubing is placed inside the curved backing plate at the perimeter of travel of the rollers. The 180º arrangement of the rollers assures that one roller is in contact with the tubing at all times. Blood flow is induced by compressing the tubing, thereby pushing the blood ahead of the moving roller. As one roller ends its compressive phase, the other has already begun its compressive phase. Since the length of tubing in the curved backing plate remains constant, flow rate depends upon the size of the tubing and the rotation rate of the rollers.

The degree of compression ("occlusiveness") of the tubing in a roller head pump is critical for extracorporeal circulation. Excessive compression exacerbates hemolysis and tubing wear, while an under occlusive roller head causes turbulence and compromises forward output. Therefore adjusting tubing compression to be barely nonocclusive results in the least amount of damage to blood components.
One of the main complications associated with roller pumps is spallation. Spallation refers to the release of micro-particles of plastic from the inner walls of the tubing in the curved backing plate, due to compression by the rollers. An optimal occlusion setting attenuates this problem. Other complications include malocclusion, miscalibration and obstruction of flow through the pump. Should the outflow of the pump become occluded, pressure in the line will progressively increase resulting in an uncontrolled, catastrophic rupture of the pump circuit. If the inflow of the pump becomes occluded, the resulting build up of negative pressure will cause cavitation and the creation of air bubbles in the pump circuit.
The centrifugal blood pump used at Children's Hospital consists of a nest of smooth plastic cones that sit inside a plastic housing. The cones are magnetically coupled with an electric motor. This magnetic coupling results in the rotational speed of the pump equaling the rotational speed of the driver magnet inside the centrifugal pump console. Rotation of the parallel cones induces centrifugal force and radial flow to the blood that passes between the cones. The spinning cones create a negative pressure that pulls blood into the pump. Once the blood is inside the pump head, energy is imparted to the blood by the spinning cones, forming a vortex. The vortex is then constrained by the outside plastic housing, generating pressure to pump the blood forward. There are no occlusive devices between the inlet and the outlet of the centrifugal pump. If the cones are not spinning, fluid can flow through the pump head in either direction.


During centrifugal pump operation, the flow generated by this device is affected both by preload and afterload. Flow increases when the preload increases or when the afterload decreases. Conversely, a decreased preload or an increased afterload will decrease pump flow. Because centrifugal pumps are pressure sensitive, they require a flow meter to monitor blood flow out of the pump. Ideally, it should be placed distal to any intra-circuit shunts so that an accurate assessment of flow to the patient can be made. The electromagnetic flow meter is not susceptible to inaccuracy from turbulence, hematocrit levels or temperature.
The main difficulty associated with centrifugal pumps is their inability to pump at low flow rates, especially in a patient who is labile. Should the patient's pressure get too high, blood could potentially flow retrograde across the pump head. Diligently attending to the pump console and maintaining a minimum flow rate of approximately 200 cc/min should eliminate the occurrence of retrograde flow.
Centrifugal pumps have several potential advantages over roller pumps. Because centrifugal pumps are sensitive to afterload pressure, a catastrophic pressure buildup in the arterial line cannot occur because flow will decrease through the pump as pressure increases. The maximum amount of pressure that a centrifugal pump can generate is in the order of 700 to 900 mmHg. Conversely, a centrifugal pump only will generate a maximum negative pressure of roughly 500 mmHg if the inflow to the pump is occluded, thereby reducing the risk of cavitation and microembolus as compared with roller pumps. Another advantage is that centrifugal pumps have better air handling characteristics should air be inadvertently introduced into the inlet side of the circuit. In a constrained vortex pump, there is high pressure at the periphery and low pressure at the center of the pump head. Because of this pressure difference, air tends to remain at the center of the pump head and not be expelled from the pump. In the event of a massive introduction of air, the pump will de-prime and the forward flow will stop. Unless a roller head is connected to a servo-controlled bubble detector that stops the pump when air is detected, the roller head would continue to pump after it is filled with air.
Colloquially speaking, centrifugal pumps are associated with greater preservation of platelets and leukocytes, decreased complement activation, reduced micro-bubble transmission and less hemolysis when compared to conventional roller pumps. However, reproduction of this data is not consistent.
On the other hand, the design of roller pumps is mechanically more simple, they are less expensive and have a lower prime volume than centrifugal pumps. Roller pumps are easier to prime and de-air and they produce a predictable output that is independent of afterload.
Although physicians and perfusionists have their preferences about which pumps should be used for surgery requiring cardiopulmonary bypass, clinical outcome studies attempting to prove that one pump type is better than another have been insufficient and inconsistent.
However, the theoretic advantages of centrifugal pumps over roller pumps become more persuasive for prolonged applications such as circulatory support.
The first centrifugal ECMO system was used at Children's Hospital in March 2001. Since then, two more centrifugal pump ECMO circuits have been used. All three patients were successfully weaned from this system.
The common denominator among these children was they were older and therefore larger than most patients who require ECMO support. In a conventional arrangement, the patient's volume is drained by gravity into the ECMO circuit and then actively pumped by the roller head through the oxygenator and back to the patient. For neonatal patients and pediatric patients who weigh less than 10 kg, gravity venous return into the ECMO circuit is adequate enough to empty the heart and maintain a flow rate that sustains their metabolic requirements. The reason that venous return is maintained in this group of patients is because of the moderately large height differential between the patient and the pump, and because the tubing lengths are relatively short.
Once a child's weight exceeds approximately 10 kg, they become progressively more difficult to drain with a conventional roller head system. Because of the decreasing height differential between the patient and the pump, the longer tubing lengths and the higher flow requirements of larger patients, gravity drainage becomes increasingly inadequate. The major resulting consequence is that their failing heart remains distended and forward flow is markedly compromised because of lack of volume. An ECMO system utilizing a centrifugal pump actively drains venous return out of the patient. The "siphon" effect of the centrifugal pump results in better drainage of the heart with a concomitant increase in forward flow to the patient.
Patient size, pathology, vascular access, cannula size and physician preference are just a few of the many factors taken into consideration when deciding on the best medium of ECMO therapy. Even though great success has been achieved for weaning patients from centrifugal ECMO at Children's Hospital, additional clinical evaluation will be necessary in order to establish its clinical application and significance. |